Explain, Describe, Compare: What the Instruction Word Is Telling You

Two students can know the same amount and score differently because one answered the question that was asked. The instruction word is the marking scheme in miniature.
Marking a set of scripts, a teacher will see the same thing repeatedly: an answer full of correct information that does not collect the marks, because it is not the kind of answer the question asked for.
The instruction word — define, describe, explain, compare, derive — is not decoration. It tells you the shape of the answer, and the marking scheme is built around it.
Define
A sentence, precise, usually in the textbook's wording. Nothing more.
Marks here are awarded against specific elements. “Pressure is force on an area” misses the part about being per unit area and the perpendicular direction, and loses the mark for each missing element regardless of how much else you write.
This is the one place where memorising exact phrasing genuinely pays. Do not paraphrase a definition.
Describe
Say what happens or what something is like. Observation, not causation.
“Describe the motion of the ball” wants: it accelerates downwards, speed increases, it bounces, each bounce is lower. It does not want gravity explained. Adding the explanation does not gain marks and costs you time you needed elsewhere.
Explain
Say why. This word is asking for cause, mechanism, reason.
This is the most commonly misread instruction. A student sees “explain the water cycle” and describes it: water evaporates, rises, condenses, falls. That is a description. The explanation is why — heat supplies energy for evaporation, temperature falls with altitude so vapour condenses, droplets coalesce until gravity exceeds the updraught.
A good test before you write: does my answer contain the word “because”, or a reason that functions like one? If not, you are probably describing.
Compare and contrast
Both things, on the same characteristics, in the same answer.
The frequent error is writing a paragraph about the first and a paragraph about the second, leaving the examiner to do the comparing. Marks are usually awarded for comparative statements, so each point must mention both: “arteries have thick walls, whereas veins have thin walls”.
A two-column table is often the fastest and clearest format, and it makes it almost impossible to forget one side.
Derive, prove, show that
The steps are the marks. The final answer alone, even if correct, usually collects very little.
Write every line, state what you are assuming, and keep the algebra visible. A student who reaches the right expression in two lines when the scheme expects five has given away three marks for tidiness.
Calculate
Formula, substitution, answer, units.
Marks are spread across those, which is why a wrong final answer with correct working scores far better than a right answer with none — and why a correct number with no units loses the last mark in almost every scheme.
A habit worth building
Underline the instruction word before you start writing. It takes a second and it is the cheapest marks available in any paper.
When practising, check your answer against the word as well as the content: did I explain, or did I describe? Students who do this for a fortnight stop making the error permanently, and it is worth several per cent across a whole paper.
Comments
Leave a reply